The Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage systematically documents the reforms of its member countries and other countries that have expanded health coverage through demand-side financing. The case studies contained in these pages are brief, comparative and modular in nature, describing the key highlights and technical features of each program.
Compare various dimensions of country reform efforts using our interactive tool.
| Program | Service delivery system | Public providers | Non-state providers | Service delivery system | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vietnam: Compulsory and Voluntary Health Insurance Schemes |
|
980 | 85 |
Beneficiaries of the national health insurance scheme are able to seek care at all public facilities. Additionally, the VSS has begun contracting with a small number private providers. Of those currently registered with the VSS, the majority are general practitioner clinics. Enrollees in all public schemes are required to register with a local facility and are expected to use that facility when they require treatment. Referrals are sanctioned when the registered facility lacks the necessary expertise to treat the patient’s condition. Health services in Vietnam are delivered by both public and private providers. Read full sectionBeneficiaries of the national health insurance scheme are able to seek care at all public facilities. Additionally, the VSS has begun contracting with a small number private providers. Of those currently registered with the VSS, the majority are general practitioner clinics. Enrollees in all public schemes are required to register with a local facility and are expected to use that facility when they require treatment. Referrals are sanctioned when the registered facility lacks the necessary expertise to treat the patient’s condition. Health services in Vietnam are delivered by both public and private providers. The health public care network is organized under state administrative units: central, provincial, district, commune and village level, with the MoH at the central level. In the public sector, there are 980 hospitals (39 central, 331 provincial and 610 district hospitals) and 11,544 primary health centers. Communes Health Centers (CHCs) provide primary health care services, including consultation, outbreak prevention and surveillance, treatment of common diseases, maternal and child health care, family planning, hygiene, and health promotion. Although CHCs are widespread, they are underutilized. On average, a CHC serves just 7,000 people. Hospitals, on the other hand, exhibit high occupancy rates, often exceeding 100%. This trend may reflect perceptions in quality of care, or may represent the strong bias in reimbursements towards higher-level facilities and inpatient care. Across Vietnam, there are approximately 35,000 private clinics and 85 private hospitals, accounting for 8.7 % of the total number of hospitals nationwide, with 5,800 beds, accounting for 3.8% of the total number of hospital beds nationwide. VSS has begun contracting with private providers, but they still represent a small portion of care provided under the national insurance program. Of private providers registered with VSS, general practitioner clinics represent the largest groups. VSS reimburses approved facilities, which include all public facilities and some contracted private facilities. Enrollees may also use non-contracted facilities, including providers abroad, but reimbursement in this case is to the patient, who pays the facility directly and subsequently files a claim, and is limited to the costs incurred on average by public facilities in Vietnam. Compulsory and Voluntary Health Insurance SchemesService delivery system Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 980
Number of non-state providers: 85 Beneficiaries of the national health insurance scheme are able to seek care at all public facilities. Additionally, the VSS has begun contracting with a small number private providers. Of those currently registered with the VSS, the majority are general practitioner clinics. Enrollees in all public schemes are required to register with a local facility and are expected to use that facility when they require treatment. Referrals are sanctioned when the registered facility lacks the necessary expertise to treat the patient’s condition. Health services in Vietnam are delivered by both public and private providers. The health public care network is organized under state administrative units: central, provincial, district, commune and village level, with the MoH at the central level. In the public sector, there are 980 hospitals (39 central, 331 provincial and 610 district hospitals) and 11,544 primary health centers. Communes Health Centers (CHCs) provide primary health care services, including consultation, outbreak prevention and surveillance, treatment of common diseases, maternal and child health care, family planning, hygiene, and health promotion. Although CHCs are widespread, they are underutilized. On average, a CHC serves just 7,000 people. Hospitals, on the other hand, exhibit high occupancy rates, often exceeding 100%. This trend may reflect perceptions in quality of care, or may represent the strong bias in reimbursements towards higher-level facilities and inpatient care. Across Vietnam, there are approximately 35,000 private clinics and 85 private hospitals, accounting for 8.7 % of the total number of hospitals nationwide, with 5,800 beds, accounting for 3.8% of the total number of hospital beds nationwide. VSS has begun contracting with private providers, but they still represent a small portion of care provided under the national insurance program. Of private providers registered with VSS, general practitioner clinics represent the largest groups. VSS reimburses approved facilities, which include all public facilities and some contracted private facilities. Enrollees may also use non-contracted facilities, including providers abroad, but reimbursement in this case is to the patient, who pays the facility directly and subsequently files a claim, and is limited to the costs incurred on average by public facilities in Vietnam. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Indonesia: Jamkesmas |
|
926 | 220 |
Jamkesmas beneficiaries are able to seek care at both public and private outlets, though covered ambulatory services are solely public. The scheme contracts with 926 hospitals for service provision, including 220 private hospitals for certain procedures. Health services across each public scheme in Indonesia are delivered by a mix of providers, with most schemes relying heavily on the public sector for delivery of care. Read full sectionJamkesmas beneficiaries are able to seek care at both public and private outlets, though covered ambulatory services are solely public. The scheme contracts with 926 hospitals for service provision, including 220 private hospitals for certain procedures. Health services across each public scheme in Indonesia are delivered by a mix of providers, with most schemes relying heavily on the public sector for delivery of care. JamkesmasService delivery system Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 926
Number of non-state providers: 220 Jamkesmas beneficiaries are able to seek care at both public and private outlets, though covered ambulatory services are solely public. The scheme contracts with 926 hospitals for service provision, including 220 private hospitals for certain procedures. Health services across each public scheme in Indonesia are delivered by a mix of providers, with most schemes relying heavily on the public sector for delivery of care. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Rwanda: Mutuelles de Sante |
|
165 | 411 |
Mutuelle members are able to access health care through all public and private non-profit health centers in Rwanda, which excludes only 10% of the country’s health care facilities that are private and for-profit. A recent law titled the Patient Roaming System was passed allowing any Mutuelle member to seek health care at any health center throughout the country. However, this has not been realized in practice as the capacity to transfer bills and funds is still limited, despite ambitions for more e-health solutions. Read full sectionMutuelle members are able to access health care through all public and private non-profit health centers in Rwanda, which excludes only 10% of the country’s health care facilities that are private and for-profit. A recent law titled the Patient Roaming System was passed allowing any Mutuelle member to seek health care at any health center throughout the country. However, this has not been realized in practice as the capacity to transfer bills and funds is still limited, despite ambitions for more e-health solutions. Rwanda has about 411 private and public health centers in total, which deliver primary and secondary care at the sector and district level. Facilities are run by for-profit entities, traditional healers, non-governmental agencies, and governmentally-assisted health organizations. Public Governmentally Assisted Health Facilities (GAHFs) are run by NGOs, religious groups, and other third parties and are partially funded by the central government. These account for approximately 40% of all primary and secondary care facilities. Primary care includes out-patient services, in-patient services, and preventive services such as immunizations, while secondary care is provided by district hospitals, which are responsible for more specialized procedures such as surgery, management of complicated cases such as severe malaria, organization of health services in health centers, administrative functioning and logistics—including the management of resources and supply of drugs— as well as supervision of community health workers. In addition, six mental health operational poles in district hospitals have been established and 30 district hospitals have integrated mental healthcare into the system. Each district health center serves approximately 200,000 people, with an average of one bed per every 1,000 people. However, these figures mask substantial variation between districts and provinces, which range from 70,000 to 480,000 people served per district. In 2006 Rwanda purchased 51 ambulances and 270 motorcycles for the district level health centers. Tertiary care is delivered at the national level at one of the few specialized, national medical institutions. There are only 4 tertiary care hospitals in Rwanda, 3 public and 1 private. While national hospitals should primarily serve as referral hospitals, in reality there is substantial overlap due to unclear delineation of responsibilities. Currently, individuals are considered to have access to medical centers if services can be reached within one and half hours by foot; approximately 85% of the population falls into this category. For the 15% of individuals living in rural areas, telemedicine is currently being used to reach geographically isolated regions. Pharmacies make generic medications available through the independent purchasing supply house called the Central Purchasing of Essential Drugs, Medical Consumables and Equipment in Rwanda (Centrale d’Achat des Medicaments Essentiels au Rwnda or CAMERWA), a non-profit organization that sells medications to district pharmacies and health facilities as a means of financing the activities of CAMERWA. The government fully finances vaccines and immunizations with the Expanded Programme on Immunizations. The table below summarizes the growth in the number of health facilities in Rwanda since the 1980s.
Mutuelles de SanteService delivery system Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 165
Number of non-state providers: 411 Mutuelle members are able to access health care through all public and private non-profit health centers in Rwanda, which excludes only 10% of the country’s health care facilities that are private and for-profit. A recent law titled the Patient Roaming System was passed allowing any Mutuelle member to seek health care at any health center throughout the country. However, this has not been realized in practice as the capacity to transfer bills and funds is still limited, despite ambitions for more e-health solutions. Rwanda has about 411 private and public health centers in total, which deliver primary and secondary care at the sector and district level. Facilities are run by for-profit entities, traditional healers, non-governmental agencies, and governmentally-assisted health organizations. Public Governmentally Assisted Health Facilities (GAHFs) are run by NGOs, religious groups, and other third parties and are partially funded by the central government. These account for approximately 40% of all primary and secondary care facilities. Primary care includes out-patient services, in-patient services, and preventive services such as immunizations, while secondary care is provided by district hospitals, which are responsible for more specialized procedures such as surgery, management of complicated cases such as severe malaria, organization of health services in health centers, administrative functioning and logistics—including the management of resources and supply of drugs— as well as supervision of community health workers. In addition, six mental health operational poles in district hospitals have been established and 30 district hospitals have integrated mental healthcare into the system. Each district health center serves approximately 200,000 people, with an average of one bed per every 1,000 people. However, these figures mask substantial variation between districts and provinces, which range from 70,000 to 480,000 people served per district. In 2006 Rwanda purchased 51 ambulances and 270 motorcycles for the district level health centers. Tertiary care is delivered at the national level at one of the few specialized, national medical institutions. There are only 4 tertiary care hospitals in Rwanda, 3 public and 1 private. While national hospitals should primarily serve as referral hospitals, in reality there is substantial overlap due to unclear delineation of responsibilities. Currently, individuals are considered to have access to medical centers if services can be reached within one and half hours by foot; approximately 85% of the population falls into this category. For the 15% of individuals living in rural areas, telemedicine is currently being used to reach geographically isolated regions. Pharmacies make generic medications available through the independent purchasing supply house called the Central Purchasing of Essential Drugs, Medical Consumables and Equipment in Rwanda (Centrale d’Achat des Medicaments Essentiels au Rwnda or CAMERWA), a non-profit organization that sells medications to district pharmacies and health facilities as a means of financing the activities of CAMERWA. The government fully finances vaccines and immunizations with the Expanded Programme on Immunizations. The table below summarizes the growth in the number of health facilities in Rwanda since the 1980s.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Nigeria: National Health Insurance System |
|
The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:
The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:
In addition, an accreditation fee is required. Currently 61 HMOs have been accredited and registered by NHIS in addition to about 6,000 primary care providers, 1,000 ancillary providers, and over 600 secondary and tertiary providers. Recently the NHIS announced the suspension of accreditation of new HMOs and providers because there is a need to strengthen the scheme and improve quality of healthcare services delivery through reaccreditation. In general, the service delivery system in Nigeria is organized on a tiered basis:
The service delivery system is mixed between private and public providers. The private health care system has grown substantially since the 1980s, to currently provide about 80% of the total health services. This sector, however, is not well regulated or supported. Of all the private facilities in Nigeria, about 50% are for-profit. Despite the large number of service providers, coverage of most key preventative and curative health services is relatively low. There are large disparities in geo-political zones, between rural and urban zones, and with regard to socio-economic status; the poorest fifth of the population are much less likely to receive medical services than their counterparts in the wealthiest 20% of the population. National Health Insurance SystemService delivery system Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers:
Number of non-state providers: The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:
In addition, an accreditation fee is required. Currently 61 HMOs have been accredited and registered by NHIS in addition to about 6,000 primary care providers, 1,000 ancillary providers, and over 600 secondary and tertiary providers. Recently the NHIS announced the suspension of accreditation of new HMOs and providers because there is a need to strengthen the scheme and improve quality of healthcare services delivery through reaccreditation. In general, the service delivery system in Nigeria is organized on a tiered basis:
The service delivery system is mixed between private and public providers. The private health care system has grown substantially since the 1980s, to currently provide about 80% of the total health services. This sector, however, is not well regulated or supported. Of all the private facilities in Nigeria, about 50% are for-profit. Despite the large number of service providers, coverage of most key preventative and curative health services is relatively low. There are large disparities in geo-political zones, between rural and urban zones, and with regard to socio-economic status; the poorest fifth of the population are much less likely to receive medical services than their counterparts in the wealthiest 20% of the population. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| India: Rajiv Aarogyasri |
|
98 | 244 |
The Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals. Read full sectionThe Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals. As of January 2010, there were a total of 342 hospitals in the network. The principal reason Aarogyasri Trust decided to work with private providers was the lack of resources in the public system. The government has been unable to attract the needed specialists to public facilities, while the private sector has rapidly expanded high quality healthcare services. A hospital or nursing home in Andhra Pradesh is eligible to be a part of the Aarogyasri network of care, established for indoor medical care and treatment of disease and injuries. The hospital should comply with the following minimum criteria:
All hospitals that qualify to be in-network must sign a memorandum of understanding with the insurance company. This Memorandum is subject to the approval of the Trust. A provision is made in the Memorandum for non-compliance/default; all such matters are looked into by the Trust. From the perspective of beneficiaries, the path to seeking care is made as simple as possible, as indicated in Figure 1.
Rajiv AarogyasriService delivery system Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 98
Number of non-state providers: 244 The Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals. As of January 2010, there were a total of 342 hospitals in the network. The principal reason Aarogyasri Trust decided to work with private providers was the lack of resources in the public system. The government has been unable to attract the needed specialists to public facilities, while the private sector has rapidly expanded high quality healthcare services. A hospital or nursing home in Andhra Pradesh is eligible to be a part of the Aarogyasri network of care, established for indoor medical care and treatment of disease and injuries. The hospital should comply with the following minimum criteria:
All hospitals that qualify to be in-network must sign a memorandum of understanding with the insurance company. This Memorandum is subject to the approval of the Trust. A provision is made in the Memorandum for non-compliance/default; all such matters are looked into by the Trust. From the perspective of beneficiaries, the path to seeking care is made as simple as possible, as indicated in Figure 1.
|
