Compare: Service delivery system

Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage

The Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage systematically documents the reforms of its member countries and other countries that have expanded health coverage through demand-side financing. The case studies contained in these pages are brief, comparative and modular in nature, describing the key highlights and technical features of each program.


Compare various dimensions of country reform efforts using our interactive tool.


Program Service delivery system Public providers Non-state providers Service delivery system
Mali: Mutuelles
  • Both Public & Non-state

The provision of care in Mali is organized in a pyramid with four levels. At the base there are the health districts (60), divided into health areas that have a community health center (CSCOM) with a dispensary, a maternity center, and a pharmacy warehouse, altogether offering a minimum package of activities (MPA). The professional team at the CSCOM is often managed by a nurse. In 2010, about 900 of the 1,030 health areas had a CSCOM. The health area, and thus the CSCOM, is run by a community health association (ASACO). There were 954 ASACOs in 2010. The ASACO signs a contract with the government of Mali, which agrees to work toward providing public health services, for which it has some available grants.

Read full section

The provision of care in Mali is organized in a pyramid with four levels. At the base there are the health districts (60), divided into health areas that have a community health center (CSCOM) with a dispensary, a maternity center, and a pharmacy warehouse, altogether offering a minimum package of activities (MPA). The professional team at the CSCOM is often managed by a nurse. In 2010, about 900 of the 1,030 health areas had a CSCOM. The health area, and thus the CSCOM, is run by a community health association (ASACO). There were 954 ASACOs in 2010. The ASACO signs a contract with the government of Mali, which agrees to work toward providing public health services, for which it has some available grants. However, it manages the CSCOM staff and the operating budget. CSCOM has the status of a non-profit private institution, and thus the system is “community” based. Roughly 87% of the population of Mali lives less than 15 km from a CSCOM. The CSCOMs account for 56% of all consultations, versus 20% for the entirely public entities (BCG 2010). The first referral takes place at the referral health center (CSRef), which is basically a district hospital. There is a CSRef in every health district. The CSRef has a more sophisticated technical support center and more highly skilled staff than at the CSCM level. The CSRef treats the cases that are referred from the CSCOMs. At the CSRef level, which has public status, there are about 25 private facilities (BCG 2010). At the third level (second referral), there are seven (7) public hospitals (EPH) located in the regional capitals. On the private side there are approximately 70 clinics at this level of the pyramid. (BCG 2010). At the top there are four level-three referring EPHs, two of which are for general medicine, while the other two are for specialized medicine.

Mutuelles

Service delivery system

Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers:
Number of non-state providers:

The provision of care in Mali is organized in a pyramid with four levels. At the base there are the health districts (60), divided into health areas that have a community health center (CSCOM) with a dispensary, a maternity center, and a pharmacy warehouse, altogether offering a minimum package of activities (MPA). The professional team at the CSCOM is often managed by a nurse. In 2010, about 900 of the 1,030 health areas had a CSCOM. The health area, and thus the CSCOM, is run by a community health association (ASACO). There were 954 ASACOs in 2010. The ASACO signs a contract with the government of Mali, which agrees to work toward providing public health services, for which it has some available grants. However, it manages the CSCOM staff and the operating budget. CSCOM has the status of a non-profit private institution, and thus the system is “community” based. Roughly 87% of the population of Mali lives less than 15 km from a CSCOM. The CSCOMs account for 56% of all consultations, versus 20% for the entirely public entities (BCG 2010). The first referral takes place at the referral health center (CSRef), which is basically a district hospital. There is a CSRef in every health district. The CSRef has a more sophisticated technical support center and more highly skilled staff than at the CSCM level. The CSRef treats the cases that are referred from the CSCOMs. At the CSRef level, which has public status, there are about 25 private facilities (BCG 2010). At the third level (second referral), there are seven (7) public hospitals (EPH) located in the regional capitals. On the private side there are approximately 70 clinics at this level of the pyramid. (BCG 2010). At the top there are four level-three referring EPHs, two of which are for general medicine, while the other two are for specialized medicine.
Nigeria: National Health Insurance System
  • Both Public & Non-state

The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:

  • All medical professionals must be in possession of the current license to practice;
  • The facility must be appropriate for service delivery;
  • Facility must be registered with state authorities;
  • Facility and staff must possess malpractice insurance.
Read full section

The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:

  • All medical professionals must be in possession of the current license to practice;
  • The facility must be appropriate for service delivery;
  • Facility must be registered with state authorities;
  • Facility and staff must possess malpractice insurance.

In addition, an accreditation fee is required. Currently 61 HMOs have been accredited and registered by NHIS in addition to about 6,000 primary care providers, 1,000 ancillary providers, and over 600 secondary and tertiary providers. Recently the NHIS announced the suspension of accreditation of new HMOs and providers because there is a need to strengthen the scheme and improve quality of healthcare services delivery through reaccreditation.

In general, the service delivery system in Nigeria is organized on a tiered basis:

  • Tertiary facilities are operated by the central government and form the highest level of health care and serve as referral centers for patients;
  • Secondary facilities are managed by state governments and provide some specialized health services;
  • Primary facilities are run by local governments and provide the most basic entry point to the health care system at health centers, clinics, and dispensaries.

The service delivery system is mixed between private and public providers. The private health care system has grown substantially since the 1980s, to currently provide about 80% of the total health services. This sector, however, is not well regulated or supported. Of all the private facilities in Nigeria, about 50% are for-profit. Despite the large number of service providers, coverage of most key preventative and curative health services is relatively low. There are large disparities in geo-political zones, between rural and urban zones, and with regard to socio-economic status; the poorest fifth of the population are much less likely to receive medical services than their counterparts in the wealthiest 20% of the population.

National Health Insurance System

Service delivery system

Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers:
Number of non-state providers:

The National Health Insurance system (NHIS) accredits both service providers and the Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) that interface between providers, the NHIS and its beneficiaries. To receive accreditation, health facilities must meet a number of requirements for the physical facility and the personnel, including:

  • All medical professionals must be in possession of the current license to practice;
  • The facility must be appropriate for service delivery;
  • Facility must be registered with state authorities;
  • Facility and staff must possess malpractice insurance.

In addition, an accreditation fee is required. Currently 61 HMOs have been accredited and registered by NHIS in addition to about 6,000 primary care providers, 1,000 ancillary providers, and over 600 secondary and tertiary providers. Recently the NHIS announced the suspension of accreditation of new HMOs and providers because there is a need to strengthen the scheme and improve quality of healthcare services delivery through reaccreditation.

In general, the service delivery system in Nigeria is organized on a tiered basis:

  • Tertiary facilities are operated by the central government and form the highest level of health care and serve as referral centers for patients;
  • Secondary facilities are managed by state governments and provide some specialized health services;
  • Primary facilities are run by local governments and provide the most basic entry point to the health care system at health centers, clinics, and dispensaries.

The service delivery system is mixed between private and public providers. The private health care system has grown substantially since the 1980s, to currently provide about 80% of the total health services. This sector, however, is not well regulated or supported. Of all the private facilities in Nigeria, about 50% are for-profit. Despite the large number of service providers, coverage of most key preventative and curative health services is relatively low. There are large disparities in geo-political zones, between rural and urban zones, and with regard to socio-economic status; the poorest fifth of the population are much less likely to receive medical services than their counterparts in the wealthiest 20% of the population.
India: Rajiv Aarogyasri
  • Both Public & Non-state
 98 244

The Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals.

Read full section

The Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals.

As of January 2010, there were a total of 342 hospitals in the network. The principal reason Aarogyasri Trust decided to work with private providers was the lack of resources in the public system. The government has been unable to attract the needed specialists to public facilities, while the private sector has rapidly expanded high quality healthcare services.

A hospital or nursing home in Andhra Pradesh is eligible to be a part of the Aarogyasri network of care, established for indoor medical care and treatment of disease and injuries. The hospital should comply with the following minimum criteria:

  • Have at least 50 inpatient medical beds
  • Be fully equipped and engaged in providing in-patient medical and surgical facilities along with diagnostic facilities (e.g., pathological tests and X-rays, E.C.G. etc.) for the care and treatment of injured or sick persons
  • Have at least one operation theater of its own where surgical operations are carried out
  • Have fully qualified nursing staff under its employment 24 hours a day
  • Have fully qualified specialist doctor(s) on premises 24 hours a day
  • Maintain complete records as required by Aarogyasri on a daily basis and able to provide necessary insured patients’ records to the insurer or his representative as and when required
  • Have sufficient experience in the specific identified field
  • Agree to deliver the package of services at the rate specified for each identified intervention/surgery as approved by the Trust. The package includes consultation, medicine, diagnostics, implants, food, cost of transportation, and hospital charges, etc. The package price should cover the entire cost of treatment of the patient from date of reporting to discharge from hospital, as well as 10 days after discharge and any complications while in hospital, making the transaction truly cashless to the patient.
  • Include the services of a Radiation Oncologist and Medical Oncologist if it desires to be empaneled for Chemo- and Radio-therapies
  • Include services of trained ENT Surgeon(s) and Auditory Verbal Therapist(s) if it desires to be empanelled for Cochlear Implant Surgery

All hospitals that qualify to be in-network must sign a memorandum of understanding with the insurance company. This Memorandum is subject to the approval of the Trust. A provision is made in the Memorandum for non-compliance/default; all such matters are looked into by the Trust.

From the perspective of beneficiaries, the path to seeking care is made as simple as possible, as indicated in Figure 1.

  • Beneficiaries approach nearby health facility (either public health clinic or area hospital) where an Aarogya Mithra is placed to help beneficiary navigate the health system. Alternatively, the beneficiary can utilize the Aarogyasri 24x7 customer care toll free number (by dialing 1800-474-7788), state’s emergency medical service (by dialing 108), or telemedicine service (by dialing 104) to reach a network hospital. Follow the links for more information on the state’s emergency medical and telemedicine services.
  • Beneficiary is seen and diagnosed by a doctor with the support of an Aarogya Mithra to ensure proper care is delivered.
  • If beneficiary needs to seek care elsewhere, he/she will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s)—the beneficiary can select which network hospital they would like to visit for the next step of care.
  • Beneficiaries may also attend the Health Camps being conducted by a network hospital in a village and can get the referral card based on the diagnosis done at the Health Camp.

Modalities of receiving care through Aarogyasri

Rajiv Aarogyasri

Service delivery system

Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 98
Number of non-state providers: 244

The Aarogyasri network includes 244 private and 98 public hospitals, all of which must meet specific structural, procedural and pricing requirements. Individuals seeking care approach their nearest in-network health facility, where Aarogya Mithras guide them through the system. If a patient needs further care, they will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s). Beneficiaries may also seek care and receive referrals at health camps held by in-network hospitals.

As of January 2010, there were a total of 342 hospitals in the network. The principal reason Aarogyasri Trust decided to work with private providers was the lack of resources in the public system. The government has been unable to attract the needed specialists to public facilities, while the private sector has rapidly expanded high quality healthcare services.

A hospital or nursing home in Andhra Pradesh is eligible to be a part of the Aarogyasri network of care, established for indoor medical care and treatment of disease and injuries. The hospital should comply with the following minimum criteria:

  • Have at least 50 inpatient medical beds
  • Be fully equipped and engaged in providing in-patient medical and surgical facilities along with diagnostic facilities (e.g., pathological tests and X-rays, E.C.G. etc.) for the care and treatment of injured or sick persons
  • Have at least one operation theater of its own where surgical operations are carried out
  • Have fully qualified nursing staff under its employment 24 hours a day
  • Have fully qualified specialist doctor(s) on premises 24 hours a day
  • Maintain complete records as required by Aarogyasri on a daily basis and able to provide necessary insured patients’ records to the insurer or his representative as and when required
  • Have sufficient experience in the specific identified field
  • Agree to deliver the package of services at the rate specified for each identified intervention/surgery as approved by the Trust. The package includes consultation, medicine, diagnostics, implants, food, cost of transportation, and hospital charges, etc. The package price should cover the entire cost of treatment of the patient from date of reporting to discharge from hospital, as well as 10 days after discharge and any complications while in hospital, making the transaction truly cashless to the patient.
  • Include the services of a Radiation Oncologist and Medical Oncologist if it desires to be empaneled for Chemo- and Radio-therapies
  • Include services of trained ENT Surgeon(s) and Auditory Verbal Therapist(s) if it desires to be empanelled for Cochlear Implant Surgery

All hospitals that qualify to be in-network must sign a memorandum of understanding with the insurance company. This Memorandum is subject to the approval of the Trust. A provision is made in the Memorandum for non-compliance/default; all such matters are looked into by the Trust.

From the perspective of beneficiaries, the path to seeking care is made as simple as possible, as indicated in Figure 1.

  • Beneficiaries approach nearby health facility (either public health clinic or area hospital) where an Aarogya Mithra is placed to help beneficiary navigate the health system. Alternatively, the beneficiary can utilize the Aarogyasri 24x7 customer care toll free number (by dialing 1800-474-7788), state’s emergency medical service (by dialing 108), or telemedicine service (by dialing 104) to reach a network hospital. Follow the links for more information on the state’s emergency medical and telemedicine services.
  • Beneficiary is seen and diagnosed by a doctor with the support of an Aarogya Mithra to ensure proper care is delivered.
  • If beneficiary needs to seek care elsewhere, he/she will be given a referral card to the appropriate network hospital(s)—the beneficiary can select which network hospital they would like to visit for the next step of care.
  • Beneficiaries may also attend the Health Camps being conducted by a network hospital in a village and can get the referral card based on the diagnosis done at the Health Camp.

Modalities of receiving care through Aarogyasri
India: RSBY
  • Both Public & Non-state
 551 1516

As of October 2009, the RSBY delivery network included 2,067 hospitals, 1,516 private and 551 public. Providers are empanelled by a state-selected insurance company based on specific structural, procedural and quality criteria, including the installation of SmartCard readers and all associated technology. A health care provider empanelled by any of the insurers in RSBY gets automatically empanelled by all the other insurers.

Read full section

As of October 2009, the RSBY delivery network included 2,067 hospitals, 1,516 private and 551 public. Providers are empanelled by a state-selected insurance company based on specific structural, procedural and quality criteria, including the installation of SmartCard readers and all associated technology. A health care provider empanelled by any of the insurers in RSBY gets automatically empanelled by all the other insurers.

After an insurance company is selected by the state, the insurance company is tasked with empaneling/certifying both public and private care providers in the program. The process is based on prescribed criteria (e.g., the service providers should possess specified basic facilities, like: have at least 10 inpatient medical beds; have specified medical and surgical facilities and diagnostic facilities, etc.). In addition, hospitals must agree to need to install necessary hardware and software to be able to process beneficiaries’ SmartCard transactions. They must also set up a dedicated RSBY desk with trained staff.

The insurer must empanel enough hospitals in each district so that beneficiaries do not need to travel great distances to get to health care services. For empanelment of public hospitals, the insurer needs to coordinate with the respective health department of the state.

Once a hospital is empanelled, a nationally-unique hospital ID number is generated so that transactions can be tracked at each hospital. Each empanelled hospital is connected with the district server of the insurance company and thus able to transfer data related to hospitalization on a daily basis.

RSBY

Service delivery system

Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers: 551
Number of non-state providers: 1516

As of October 2009, the RSBY delivery network included 2,067 hospitals, 1,516 private and 551 public. Providers are empanelled by a state-selected insurance company based on specific structural, procedural and quality criteria, including the installation of SmartCard readers and all associated technology. A health care provider empanelled by any of the insurers in RSBY gets automatically empanelled by all the other insurers.

After an insurance company is selected by the state, the insurance company is tasked with empaneling/certifying both public and private care providers in the program. The process is based on prescribed criteria (e.g., the service providers should possess specified basic facilities, like: have at least 10 inpatient medical beds; have specified medical and surgical facilities and diagnostic facilities, etc.). In addition, hospitals must agree to need to install necessary hardware and software to be able to process beneficiaries’ SmartCard transactions. They must also set up a dedicated RSBY desk with trained staff.

The insurer must empanel enough hospitals in each district so that beneficiaries do not need to travel great distances to get to health care services. For empanelment of public hospitals, the insurer needs to coordinate with the respective health department of the state.

Once a hospital is empanelled, a nationally-unique hospital ID number is generated so that transactions can be tracked at each hospital. Each empanelled hospital is connected with the district server of the insurance company and thus able to transfer data related to hospitalization on a daily basis.
Thailand: Universal Coverage Scheme
  • Both Public & Non-state

The UCS service delivery network includes both public and private health care facilities. However, prior to registration, private health facilities must submit required documentation and are investigated according to standard criteria of the UCS. No similar process exists for public health care facilities and they are automatically registered in the delivery network.

Read full section

The UCS service delivery network includes both public and private health care facilities. However, prior to registration, private health facilities must submit required documentation and are investigated according to standard criteria of the UCS. No similar process exists for public health care facilities and they are automatically registered in the delivery network.

The Thai insurance system is based on the health system that is founded on the principles of primary care. For UCS in particular, primary care provider units (PCUs) have been designated as gatekeepers to provide care for UCS beneficiaries. As gatekeepers, PCUs are expected to provide people in their catchment areas with continuous and comprehensive care with a holistic approach. According to the services provided, health facilities under the UCS can be classified into three groups:

  • Contracting unit for primary care: These CUPs are primary health facilities offering curative, promotive, preventive, and rehabilitative services such as ambulatory care, home care, and community care. They can be facilities ranging from community hospitals to tertiary care public or private hospitals. Each CUP has its own catchment area and population.
  • Contracting unit for secondary care: The CUSs are health facilities that offer secondary care, mainly in patient health services. They can be facilities ranging from community hospitals to tertiary care public or private hospitals.
  • Contracting unit for tertiary care: The CUTs provide expensive care and specialized care with high technologies. They can be regional hospitals, university hospitals, or specialized health institutes.

Private health facilities are investigated by the UCS before contracts are signed. There is no such investigation for public health care facilities as they are automatically registered in the delivery network.

In principle, UCS beneficiaries are free to choose their primary providers. However, because of limited number of primary providers in rural areas, beneficiaries are assigned mainly to public primary providers close to their communities or their workplaces.

Universal Coverage Scheme

Service delivery system

Types of Providers Empanelled: Both Public & Non-state
Number of public providers:
Number of non-state providers:

The UCS service delivery network includes both public and private health care facilities. However, prior to registration, private health facilities must submit required documentation and are investigated according to standard criteria of the UCS. No similar process exists for public health care facilities and they are automatically registered in the delivery network.

The Thai insurance system is based on the health system that is founded on the principles of primary care. For UCS in particular, primary care provider units (PCUs) have been designated as gatekeepers to provide care for UCS beneficiaries. As gatekeepers, PCUs are expected to provide people in their catchment areas with continuous and comprehensive care with a holistic approach. According to the services provided, health facilities under the UCS can be classified into three groups:

  • Contracting unit for primary care: These CUPs are primary health facilities offering curative, promotive, preventive, and rehabilitative services such as ambulatory care, home care, and community care. They can be facilities ranging from community hospitals to tertiary care public or private hospitals. Each CUP has its own catchment area and population.
  • Contracting unit for secondary care: The CUSs are health facilities that offer secondary care, mainly in patient health services. They can be facilities ranging from community hospitals to tertiary care public or private hospitals.
  • Contracting unit for tertiary care: The CUTs provide expensive care and specialized care with high technologies. They can be regional hospitals, university hospitals, or specialized health institutes.

Private health facilities are investigated by the UCS before contracts are signed. There is no such investigation for public health care facilities as they are automatically registered in the delivery network.

In principle, UCS beneficiaries are free to choose their primary providers. However, because of limited number of primary providers in rural areas, beneficiaries are assigned mainly to public primary providers close to their communities or their workplaces.