The Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage systematically documents the reforms of its member countries and other countries that have expanded health coverage through demand-side financing. The case studies contained in these pages are brief, comparative and modular in nature, describing the key highlights and technical features of each program.
Compare various dimensions of country reform efforts using our interactive tool.
| Program | Provider Payment Mechanisms | Provider payment mechanisms |
|---|---|---|
| Estonia: Estonian Health Insurance Fund |
|
The EHIF negotiates capped cost and volume contracts with hospitals at the start of each year. These contracts contain provisions on service quality and access, as well as an extended cost and volume section. The contracting process begins with a needs assessment based on historical data regarding health service utilization along with existing waiting times. The EHIF does not have to contract with all providers. Still most of the services are purchased from hospital master plan hospitals with which EHIF has contracts. A small amount of funds go to selective contracting which provides private providers the opportunity to get some health insurance funding. These private providers, however, tend to be primarily funded through OOP payments. A large part of the standard contract conditions are negotiated with the Hospital Association, but there are also financial appendices that are negotiated with each provider individually. Contracts are monitored quarterly using the Management Information System. Read full sectionThe EHIF negotiates capped cost and volume contracts with hospitals at the start of each year. These contracts contain provisions on service quality and access, as well as an extended cost and volume section. The contracting process begins with a needs assessment based on historical data regarding health service utilization along with existing waiting times. The EHIF does not have to contract with all providers. Still most of the services are purchased from hospital master plan hospitals with which EHIF has contracts. A small amount of funds go to selective contracting which provides private providers the opportunity to get some health insurance funding. These private providers, however, tend to be primarily funded through OOP payments. A large part of the standard contract conditions are negotiated with the Hospital Association, but there are also financial appendices that are negotiated with each provider individually. Contracts are monitored quarterly using the Management Information System.
Actual payment methods and prices are regulated in a single government health service list that lies outside of the contract negotiation process and which is updated at least once per year. All providers are paid the same prices. The list includes over 2,000 different items and a range of different payment methods. Outpatient care is normally paid on a fee-for-service basis and inpatient care is paid with a mix of fee-for-service, per diem, and diagnosis-related group (DRG) methods. Primary care family physicians are paid through per capita payments that are adjusted based on the age of the patients. If a family physician has fewer than 1,200 patients, he will still receive a capitation payment for 1,200 patients in order to cover fixed costs. Family physicians can also receive additional fee-for-service payments up to 32% of the capitation amount received. Contracts for family medicine are agreed to between the EHIF and the Estonian Association of Family Doctors. The financial stipulations of the contracts with particular family doctors are reviewed every quarter in order to align with changes in the number of patients on the practice list. Specialist care is also compensated using different types of payment methods depending on the services provided. These methods include fee-for-service, visit fees, per diem, diagnosis-related group, and case-based complex pricing. Since the 1990s, there has been a gradual move away from fee-for service toward case-based payments.
Estonian Health Insurance FundProvider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Fee-for-service, Capitation, Diagnosis-Related Groups The EHIF negotiates capped cost and volume contracts with hospitals at the start of each year. These contracts contain provisions on service quality and access, as well as an extended cost and volume section. The contracting process begins with a needs assessment based on historical data regarding health service utilization along with existing waiting times. The EHIF does not have to contract with all providers. Still most of the services are purchased from hospital master plan hospitals with which EHIF has contracts. A small amount of funds go to selective contracting which provides private providers the opportunity to get some health insurance funding. These private providers, however, tend to be primarily funded through OOP payments. A large part of the standard contract conditions are negotiated with the Hospital Association, but there are also financial appendices that are negotiated with each provider individually. Contracts are monitored quarterly using the Management Information System.
Actual payment methods and prices are regulated in a single government health service list that lies outside of the contract negotiation process and which is updated at least once per year. All providers are paid the same prices. The list includes over 2,000 different items and a range of different payment methods. Outpatient care is normally paid on a fee-for-service basis and inpatient care is paid with a mix of fee-for-service, per diem, and diagnosis-related group (DRG) methods. Primary care family physicians are paid through per capita payments that are adjusted based on the age of the patients. If a family physician has fewer than 1,200 patients, he will still receive a capitation payment for 1,200 patients in order to cover fixed costs. Family physicians can also receive additional fee-for-service payments up to 32% of the capitation amount received. Contracts for family medicine are agreed to between the EHIF and the Estonian Association of Family Doctors. The financial stipulations of the contracts with particular family doctors are reviewed every quarter in order to align with changes in the number of patients on the practice list. Specialist care is also compensated using different types of payment methods depending on the services provided. These methods include fee-for-service, visit fees, per diem, diagnosis-related group, and case-based complex pricing. Since the 1990s, there has been a gradual move away from fee-for service toward case-based payments.
|
| Colombia: General System of Social Security in Health |
|
EPSs and EPSSs are free to establish payment levels and payment mechanisms for services that they purchase from providers. Both entities have used the fee schedules, adjusted for inflation, developed by the pre-reform public health plans as ceilings for price negotiations. As of 2008, provider associations were forcefully seeking the establishment of price floors by the MPS. Read full sectionEPSs and EPSSs are free to establish payment levels and payment mechanisms for services that they purchase from providers. Both entities have used the fee schedules, adjusted for inflation, developed by the pre-reform public health plans as ceilings for price negotiations. As of 2008, provider associations were forcefully seeking the establishment of price floors by the MPS. There are two payment mechanisms common to both EPSs and EPSSs. In general, preventive and primary care services are contracted on a capitation basis. Most specialist and hospital care, however, is paid for either on a fee-for-service basis or by a services package. The CR and SR enrollees must also pay copayments, which vary according to an individual’s income. CR copayments are charged according to salary income. Enrollees with salaries lower than 2 minimum monthly salaries (mms) have a maximum copayment of USD46.70 annually. The maximum copayment for enrollees with incomes in the range of 2-5 mms is USD 195.20 annually. Finally, enrollees with incomes greater than 5 mms have a maximum copayment of USD390.30 annually. SR copayments are set according to SISBEN category. The poorest enrollees, who are classified in category 1, pay co copayments. On the opposite end of the scale, enrollees classified in category 3 pay 10% of the service value. General System of Social Security in HealthProvider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Fee-for-service, Capitation EPSs and EPSSs are free to establish payment levels and payment mechanisms for services that they purchase from providers. Both entities have used the fee schedules, adjusted for inflation, developed by the pre-reform public health plans as ceilings for price negotiations. As of 2008, provider associations were forcefully seeking the establishment of price floors by the MPS. There are two payment mechanisms common to both EPSs and EPSSs. In general, preventive and primary care services are contracted on a capitation basis. Most specialist and hospital care, however, is paid for either on a fee-for-service basis or by a services package. The CR and SR enrollees must also pay copayments, which vary according to an individual’s income. CR copayments are charged according to salary income. Enrollees with salaries lower than 2 minimum monthly salaries (mms) have a maximum copayment of USD46.70 annually. The maximum copayment for enrollees with incomes in the range of 2-5 mms is USD 195.20 annually. Finally, enrollees with incomes greater than 5 mms have a maximum copayment of USD390.30 annually. SR copayments are set according to SISBEN category. The poorest enrollees, who are classified in category 1, pay co copayments. On the opposite end of the scale, enrollees classified in category 3 pay 10% of the service value. |
| Kyrgyz Republic: Mandatory Health Insurance Fund (MHIF) |
|
Outpatient care is funded through capitation-based payments while hospital services are funded through case-based payments. The capitation formula for primary care is adjusted by coefficients for rural, small towns, and mountainous areas. This leads to cross-subsidization across geographical boundaries. Read full sectionOutpatient care is funded through capitation-based payments while hospital services are funded through case-based payments. The capitation formula for primary care is adjusted by coefficients for rural, small towns, and mountainous areas. This leads to cross-subsidization across geographical boundaries. The base primary care capitation rate (before adjustment coefficients) is based on two variables, the estimated number of enrollees that are expected to be enrolled in a family group practice over the coming year, and the size of the budget. The case-based payments for hospital services introduced the idea of output-based payments to the Kyrgyz health system. The system for grouping cases, generally called clinical statistical groups, was based on American diagnosis-related-groups, but was created with Kyrgyz utilization and cost data. This new system enabled an expansion of the budget management autonomy of hospital administrators, although hospital autonomy and management capacity is still an issue on the reform agenda. The republican MHIF and its territorial branches administer the national pool of funds for the SGBP and are responsible for making all case- and capitation-based payments. Per-case payment rates are defined prospectively but payments are made on a monthly basis. In order to avoid provider selection, providers receive higher payments for treating exempt patients and those with lower copayments. A key to the success of the MHIF as the single-payer for the SGBP has been the continuous development and refinement of financial and clinical information systems to operate the provider payment systems and ensure good financial reporting and fiduciary risk mitigation. Mandatory Health Insurance Fund (MHIF)Provider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Capitation, Diagnosis-Related Groups Outpatient care is funded through capitation-based payments while hospital services are funded through case-based payments. The capitation formula for primary care is adjusted by coefficients for rural, small towns, and mountainous areas. This leads to cross-subsidization across geographical boundaries. The base primary care capitation rate (before adjustment coefficients) is based on two variables, the estimated number of enrollees that are expected to be enrolled in a family group practice over the coming year, and the size of the budget. The case-based payments for hospital services introduced the idea of output-based payments to the Kyrgyz health system. The system for grouping cases, generally called clinical statistical groups, was based on American diagnosis-related-groups, but was created with Kyrgyz utilization and cost data. This new system enabled an expansion of the budget management autonomy of hospital administrators, although hospital autonomy and management capacity is still an issue on the reform agenda. The republican MHIF and its territorial branches administer the national pool of funds for the SGBP and are responsible for making all case- and capitation-based payments. Per-case payment rates are defined prospectively but payments are made on a monthly basis. In order to avoid provider selection, providers receive higher payments for treating exempt patients and those with lower copayments. A key to the success of the MHIF as the single-payer for the SGBP has been the continuous development and refinement of financial and clinical information systems to operate the provider payment systems and ensure good financial reporting and fiduciary risk mitigation. |
| Nigeria: National Health Insurance System |
|
Patients are allowed to choose their primary provider from the list of accredited facilities, which includes both public and private providers. The provider network is used for access and secondary referrals, which acts to control costs and maintain viability of the system. Provider payment mechanisms are primarily determined by the National Health Insurance System (NHIS) Governing Council. Read full sectionPatients are allowed to choose their primary provider from the list of accredited facilities, which includes both public and private providers. The provider network is used for access and secondary referrals, which acts to control costs and maintain viability of the system. Provider payment mechanisms are primarily determined by the National Health Insurance System (NHIS) Governing Council. For private insurers, this is determined between HMOs and Providers, with oversight from the central government, and referral to specialist care follows guidelines that are managed accordingly. Decree 35 determined that the only lawful payment systems to be included in NHIS are capitation, fee-for-service, per diem, or case payment. A capitation system is the predominant form of provider payment used to pay primary healthcare facilities, while secondary and tertiary healthcare facilities are paid by fee for service and per diem. National Health Insurance SystemProvider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Fee-for-service, Capitation Patients are allowed to choose their primary provider from the list of accredited facilities, which includes both public and private providers. The provider network is used for access and secondary referrals, which acts to control costs and maintain viability of the system. Provider payment mechanisms are primarily determined by the National Health Insurance System (NHIS) Governing Council. For private insurers, this is determined between HMOs and Providers, with oversight from the central government, and referral to specialist care follows guidelines that are managed accordingly. Decree 35 determined that the only lawful payment systems to be included in NHIS are capitation, fee-for-service, per diem, or case payment. A capitation system is the predominant form of provider payment used to pay primary healthcare facilities, while secondary and tertiary healthcare facilities are paid by fee for service and per diem. |
| India: Rajiv Aarogyasri |
|
Providers are paid on a by-intervention basis, where a specified rate is set by Aarogyasri Trust in consultation with medical experts. For each approved procedure, the payment covers the entire cost of treatment, from the date of admission to discharge, as well as a maximum of 10 days after the discharge and any complications while in the hospital. The package rate includes consultation, medicine, diagnostics, implants, food, cost of transportation, hospital charges, and post-operative hospital stay. Read full sectionProviders are paid on a by-intervention basis, where a specified rate is set by Aarogyasri Trust in consultation with medical experts. For each approved procedure, the payment covers the entire cost of treatment, from the date of admission to discharge, as well as a maximum of 10 days after the discharge and any complications while in the hospital. The package rate includes consultation, medicine, diagnostics, implants, food, cost of transportation, hospital charges, and post-operative hospital stay. A comprehensive list of benefits and associated payment pricing can be found on the Aarogyasri web site. Seeking care is truly cashless for the patient. On the back-end, the provider must submit a pre-authorization to the insurance company (Aarogyasri I procedures) or to Aarogyasri Healthcare Trust (for Aarogyasri II procedures). The insurance company/Trust appoints medical officers who work on pre-authorizations. After pre-authorization and treatment, the insurance company or Trust (depending on which Procedure the beneficiary was enrolled in) will settle claims from hospitals within seven days of receipt of claim, discharge summary, and a satisfaction letter from the patient. To prevent fraudulent claims, the claim settlement history of each hospital is scrutinized and reviewed by the Trust at regular intervals. In addition, the insurance company recruits specialized doctors, known as vigilance officers, for regular inspection of hospitals. These specialists also attend to complaints from beneficiaries directly or through Arogya Mithras for any deficiency in services reported. The specialists also to ensure proper care and counseling for the patient at network hospitals by coordinating with Aarogya Mithras and hospital authorities. Rajiv AarogyasriProvider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Fee-for-service, Diagnosis-Related Groups Providers are paid on a by-intervention basis, where a specified rate is set by Aarogyasri Trust in consultation with medical experts. For each approved procedure, the payment covers the entire cost of treatment, from the date of admission to discharge, as well as a maximum of 10 days after the discharge and any complications while in the hospital. The package rate includes consultation, medicine, diagnostics, implants, food, cost of transportation, hospital charges, and post-operative hospital stay. A comprehensive list of benefits and associated payment pricing can be found on the Aarogyasri web site. Seeking care is truly cashless for the patient. On the back-end, the provider must submit a pre-authorization to the insurance company (Aarogyasri I procedures) or to Aarogyasri Healthcare Trust (for Aarogyasri II procedures). The insurance company/Trust appoints medical officers who work on pre-authorizations. After pre-authorization and treatment, the insurance company or Trust (depending on which Procedure the beneficiary was enrolled in) will settle claims from hospitals within seven days of receipt of claim, discharge summary, and a satisfaction letter from the patient. To prevent fraudulent claims, the claim settlement history of each hospital is scrutinized and reviewed by the Trust at regular intervals. In addition, the insurance company recruits specialized doctors, known as vigilance officers, for regular inspection of hospitals. These specialists also attend to complaints from beneficiaries directly or through Arogya Mithras for any deficiency in services reported. The specialists also to ensure proper care and counseling for the patient at network hospitals by coordinating with Aarogya Mithras and hospital authorities. |
| Brazil: Unified Health System (SUS) |
|
Primary care providers at the municipal level are paid on a per capita basis. Transfers from state and federal resources trickle down to the municipal level through streams such as the basic health program (PAB), the PSF, and the PACS. Read full sectionPrimary care providers at the municipal level are paid on a per capita basis. Transfers from state and federal resources trickle down to the municipal level through streams such as the basic health program (PAB), the PSF, and the PACS. The same method of provider payments is used for both private and public providers under the SUS. Payments for hospital stays and complex procedures are based on Hospital Stay Authorization (AIH) codes. The AIH payment system is a procedure- or service-based rate system that is not linked to resource usage or costs. Fixed values are established per disease and necessary procedures. Hospitals that undertake complex procedures receive additional resources to maintain their facilities. Ambulatory services are paid by the health funds based on Ambulatory Care Units (UCA) plus an additional fixed amount for each service rendered.
Unified Health System (SUS)Provider payment mechanisms Provider Payment Mechanisms: Capitation, Diagnosis-Related Groups Primary care providers at the municipal level are paid on a per capita basis. Transfers from state and federal resources trickle down to the municipal level through streams such as the basic health program (PAB), the PSF, and the PACS. The same method of provider payments is used for both private and public providers under the SUS. Payments for hospital stays and complex procedures are based on Hospital Stay Authorization (AIH) codes. The AIH payment system is a procedure- or service-based rate system that is not linked to resource usage or costs. Fixed values are established per disease and necessary procedures. Hospitals that undertake complex procedures receive additional resources to maintain their facilities. Ambulatory services are paid by the health funds based on Ambulatory Care Units (UCA) plus an additional fixed amount for each service rendered.
|
