The Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage systematically documents the reforms of its member countries and other countries that have expanded health coverage through demand-side financing. The case studies contained in these pages are brief, comparative and modular in nature, describing the key highlights and technical features of each program.
Compare various dimensions of country reform efforts using our interactive tool.
| Program | Target population | Coverage | Population covered | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rwanda: Mutuelles de Sante |
|
7.9 million |
Enrollment in the Mutuelle system is voluntary and is primarily coordinated at the district and sector level. Each community-based Mutuelle is responsible for increasing enrollment, maintaining re-enrollment, educating the population about the program, verifying the number of participants in each household, and collecting membership contributions. Outreach is done most frequently at the community level via church services, radio broadcasts, etc, and tends to focus largely on the rural and informal sector in order to most effectively target those individuals unable to access formal health insurance through other means. Read full sectionEnrollment in the Mutuelle system is voluntary and is primarily coordinated at the district and sector level. Each community-based Mutuelle is responsible for increasing enrollment, maintaining re-enrollment, educating the population about the program, verifying the number of participants in each household, and collecting membership contributions. Outreach is done most frequently at the community level via church services, radio broadcasts, etc, and tends to focus largely on the rural and informal sector in order to most effectively target those individuals unable to access formal health insurance through other means. Enrollment for Rwanda Health Insurance Scheme (La Rwandaise d’Assurance Maladie or RAMA) and Military Medical Insurance (MMI) are coordinated through the government and employers. Initially only civil servants and their families were covered with RAMA, however, in 2003 coverage expanded to all those employed in both the public and the private sector. In 2006 RAMA only covered approximately 2.2% of the population. Coverage through MMI is provided for all members of the Rwandan Defense Force. Family members of MMI affiliates are covered under the same conditions as in RAMA. The exact number of beneficiaries is difficult to calculate due to national security issues but an estimated figure of 100,000 individuals or approximately 1.1% of the total Rwandan population is estimated to be covered. Combined, these programs insure less than 5% of the population. The result of these health insurance programs has been an incredible upsurge in health insurance enrollment. USAID estimates that in 2010 approximately 92% of the population had health coverage, up from about 10% in 1999 since the implementation of the Community-Based Health Initiatives (CBHI). Geographically, enrollment has expanded from about 4 provinces to all 11 provinces. After national expansion of CBHI, participation increased coverage to 5.8 million persons, about 70% of the population. The Ministry of Health has stated that the rapid uptake seen in the early years of the program undoubtedly speaks to the communal and grassroots dynamics of the country.
Mutuelles de SantePopulation covered Target Populations: Below Poverty Line, Informal Sector
Coverage Level: 7.9 million Enrollment in the Mutuelle system is voluntary and is primarily coordinated at the district and sector level. Each community-based Mutuelle is responsible for increasing enrollment, maintaining re-enrollment, educating the population about the program, verifying the number of participants in each household, and collecting membership contributions. Outreach is done most frequently at the community level via church services, radio broadcasts, etc, and tends to focus largely on the rural and informal sector in order to most effectively target those individuals unable to access formal health insurance through other means. Enrollment for Rwanda Health Insurance Scheme (La Rwandaise d’Assurance Maladie or RAMA) and Military Medical Insurance (MMI) are coordinated through the government and employers. Initially only civil servants and their families were covered with RAMA, however, in 2003 coverage expanded to all those employed in both the public and the private sector. In 2006 RAMA only covered approximately 2.2% of the population. Coverage through MMI is provided for all members of the Rwandan Defense Force. Family members of MMI affiliates are covered under the same conditions as in RAMA. The exact number of beneficiaries is difficult to calculate due to national security issues but an estimated figure of 100,000 individuals or approximately 1.1% of the total Rwandan population is estimated to be covered. Combined, these programs insure less than 5% of the population. The result of these health insurance programs has been an incredible upsurge in health insurance enrollment. USAID estimates that in 2010 approximately 92% of the population had health coverage, up from about 10% in 1999 since the implementation of the Community-Based Health Initiatives (CBHI). Geographically, enrollment has expanded from about 4 provinces to all 11 provinces. After national expansion of CBHI, participation increased coverage to 5.8 million persons, about 70% of the population. The Ministry of Health has stated that the rapid uptake seen in the early years of the program undoubtedly speaks to the communal and grassroots dynamics of the country.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Chile: National Health Fund (FONASA) |
|
11 million |
Enrollment into FONASA or ISAPREs tends to be tied to income, with lower income individuals joining FONASA and higher income individuals enrolling in an ISAPRE. In 2003, the mean income of ISAPRE members was four times higher than that of FONASA members. Formal sector workers must enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income or pension (2,000USD monthly maximum) to healthcare. Those who do not work in the formal sector have the option to enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income, but are not required to do so. These groups can enroll with either FONASA or an ISAPRE of their choice. The indigent and the unemployed are entitled to free coverage by FONASA. Read full sectionEnrollment into FONASA or ISAPREs tends to be tied to income, with lower income individuals joining FONASA and higher income individuals enrolling in an ISAPRE. In 2003, the mean income of ISAPRE members was four times higher than that of FONASA members. Formal sector workers must enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income or pension (2,000USD monthly maximum) to healthcare. Those who do not work in the formal sector have the option to enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income, but are not required to do so. These groups can enroll with either FONASA or an ISAPRE of their choice. The indigent and the unemployed are entitled to free coverage by FONASA. FONASA divides its beneficiary population into four categories based on income. Category A is composed of the indigent, category B is composed of the very low income population, category C is composed of the lower-middle income population, and category D is composed of the higher-middle income population. Copayment rates are based on these categories. In 2005, FONASA enrollees numbered 11,329,481, about 70% of the population. ISAPRE enrollees accounted for 2,660,338 during the same year, equaling 17% of the population. In 2006 there were 15 ISAPREs, but over two thirds of members belonged to the three largest: Banmedica, Consalud, and ING Salud. Open ISAPREs are available to the population at large, while closed ISAPREs are only available to particular groups of individuals such as professional associations. Table 1: Individuals covered per category
Source: Bitran, R., Urcullo, G., 106 National Health Fund (FONASA)Population covered Target Populations: All populations
Coverage Level: 11 million Enrollment into FONASA or ISAPREs tends to be tied to income, with lower income individuals joining FONASA and higher income individuals enrolling in an ISAPRE. In 2003, the mean income of ISAPRE members was four times higher than that of FONASA members. Formal sector workers must enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income or pension (2,000USD monthly maximum) to healthcare. Those who do not work in the formal sector have the option to enroll by allocating 7% of their monthly income, but are not required to do so. These groups can enroll with either FONASA or an ISAPRE of their choice. The indigent and the unemployed are entitled to free coverage by FONASA. FONASA divides its beneficiary population into four categories based on income. Category A is composed of the indigent, category B is composed of the very low income population, category C is composed of the lower-middle income population, and category D is composed of the higher-middle income population. Copayment rates are based on these categories. In 2005, FONASA enrollees numbered 11,329,481, about 70% of the population. ISAPRE enrollees accounted for 2,660,338 during the same year, equaling 17% of the population. In 2006 there were 15 ISAPREs, but over two thirds of members belonged to the three largest: Banmedica, Consalud, and ING Salud. Open ISAPREs are available to the population at large, while closed ISAPREs are only available to particular groups of individuals such as professional associations. Table 1: Individuals covered per category
Source: Bitran, R., Urcullo, G., 106 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Ghana: National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) |
|
12 million |
Each Ghanaian district has a District Wide Mutual Health Insurance (DWMHI) scheme, and each metropolis has two such schemes. Contributions to SSNIT are automatic for members of the DWMHIs. The DWMHI schemes have their own management structures and a certain level of autonomy in the setting of premiums and other costs, although these have to be kept within the limits established by the NHIA. As with the other CBHI schemes, membership is voluntary, although there are plans to eventually introduce compulsory membership. Read full sectionEach Ghanaian district has a District Wide Mutual Health Insurance (DWMHI) scheme, and each metropolis has two such schemes. Contributions to SSNIT are automatic for members of the DWMHIs. The DWMHI schemes have their own management structures and a certain level of autonomy in the setting of premiums and other costs, although these have to be kept within the limits established by the NHIA. As with the other CBHI schemes, membership is voluntary, although there are plans to eventually introduce compulsory membership. The DWMHI schemes have their own management structures and have a certain level of autonomy in the setting of premiums and the charging of other costs, although these have to be kept within the limits established by the NHIA. As one of the reasons for the NHIS’s existence is to stop out-of-pocket healthcare payments, there are no deductibles, and no copayments have to be made by NHIS members when accessing healthcare. As one of the reasons for the NHIS's existence is to stop out-of-pocket healthcare payments, there are no deductibles and no copayments. Enrollment: Contributions to SSNIT are automatic for members of DWMHI schemes because of the health insurance deductions made from their SSNIT contributions, and are only required to pay an initial registration fee. The premium structure therefore applies only to those who work in the informal economy or who are not SSNIT contributors. These members pay their premiums to the DWMHI schemes directly. The schemes employ collectors who move between houses and market stalls to receive premium payments. Alternatively, premiums can be paid to banks, or to designated pharmacies or ‘chemical shops.’ Premiums can be paid at any time during the year – there is no set registration period. Exemptions: Exemptions from premium payments exist for SSNIT contributors, SSNIT pensioners, those over the age of 70, and for those classed as indigent. Indigents are classified as those people who:
Currently all children under the age under 18 are exempted from NHIS premium payments irrespective of the NHIS membership status of their parents. If parents are NHIS members, then children are covered for free. However, if parents are not NHIS members, children cannot access benefits. National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS)Population covered Target Populations: All populations
Coverage Level: 12 million Each Ghanaian district has a District Wide Mutual Health Insurance (DWMHI) scheme, and each metropolis has two such schemes. Contributions to SSNIT are automatic for members of the DWMHIs. The DWMHI schemes have their own management structures and a certain level of autonomy in the setting of premiums and other costs, although these have to be kept within the limits established by the NHIA. As with the other CBHI schemes, membership is voluntary, although there are plans to eventually introduce compulsory membership. The DWMHI schemes have their own management structures and have a certain level of autonomy in the setting of premiums and the charging of other costs, although these have to be kept within the limits established by the NHIA. As one of the reasons for the NHIS’s existence is to stop out-of-pocket healthcare payments, there are no deductibles, and no copayments have to be made by NHIS members when accessing healthcare. As one of the reasons for the NHIS's existence is to stop out-of-pocket healthcare payments, there are no deductibles and no copayments. Enrollment: Contributions to SSNIT are automatic for members of DWMHI schemes because of the health insurance deductions made from their SSNIT contributions, and are only required to pay an initial registration fee. The premium structure therefore applies only to those who work in the informal economy or who are not SSNIT contributors. These members pay their premiums to the DWMHI schemes directly. The schemes employ collectors who move between houses and market stalls to receive premium payments. Alternatively, premiums can be paid to banks, or to designated pharmacies or ‘chemical shops.’ Premiums can be paid at any time during the year – there is no set registration period. Exemptions: Exemptions from premium payments exist for SSNIT contributors, SSNIT pensioners, those over the age of 70, and for those classed as indigent. Indigents are classified as those people who:
Currently all children under the age under 18 are exempted from NHIS premium payments irrespective of the NHIS membership status of their parents. If parents are NHIS members, then children are covered for free. However, if parents are not NHIS members, children cannot access benefits. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Philippines: PhilHealth |
|
75 million |
PhilHealth coverage is theoretically available to the entire population. The enrollment process differs based on the population group. For example, all formal sector workers must enroll at the start of employment. Read full sectionPhilHealth coverage is theoretically available to the entire population. The enrollment process differs based on the population group. For example, all formal sector workers must enroll at the start of employment. The poor are identified and enrolled by the local government. The population is tagged to one of the four major population categorizations:
The benefits package is essentially the same for each population group. The exception is for indigents and the Overseas Filipino Workers (OFW) who have additional outpatient primary care benefits (with the providers paid by capitation) however these benefits are available only through public providers. However, the enrollment process for each population category differs. For the formal sector, employees are enrolled upon the start of employment. It is mandatory that all employees enroll in health insurance. No exceptions are allowed for the size of the company. For the poor, the local government determines “poorness” and enrolls those who are determined poor. For the rest of the population there is open enrollment—one can walk into a local enrollment office anytime to enroll. While enrollment is mandatory only for the formal sector, for the remainder of the population, it is “construed” as voluntary although the law can be interpreted as being mandatory. There is an ongoing debate on the issue of mandated versus voluntary enrollment. Enrollment in PhilHealth is by family so the premium paid covers the member, the spouse, eligible children (those less than 21 years of age), and eligible parents (those 60 years and above and who depend financially on the member). Given that enrollment is by family, documentation of proof of marriage and birth(s) are required before spouses and children are enrolled. This is a problem for indigenous population as they usually do not have marriage and birth certificates. While the country has achieved significant strides in moving towards universal enrollment, covering the poor and informal sectors remains a challenge, with methods to enroll these populations through organized groups gaining very little traction. There is much ongoing discussion regarding the need for the central government to finance and/or subsidize the enrollment of the nation’s entire poor population. Leaving financial responsibility for insuring the poorest to local governments, coupled with a refusal to outright declare insurance as mandatory for all populations, makes it nearly impossible for the government to reach universal health coverage. It also forces PhilHealth to invest heavily in marketing campaigns for the program to local governments. PhilHealthPopulation covered Target Populations: All populations
Coverage Level: 75 million PhilHealth coverage is theoretically available to the entire population. The enrollment process differs based on the population group. For example, all formal sector workers must enroll at the start of employment. The poor are identified and enrolled by the local government. The population is tagged to one of the four major population categorizations:
The benefits package is essentially the same for each population group. The exception is for indigents and the Overseas Filipino Workers (OFW) who have additional outpatient primary care benefits (with the providers paid by capitation) however these benefits are available only through public providers. However, the enrollment process for each population category differs. For the formal sector, employees are enrolled upon the start of employment. It is mandatory that all employees enroll in health insurance. No exceptions are allowed for the size of the company. For the poor, the local government determines “poorness” and enrolls those who are determined poor. For the rest of the population there is open enrollment—one can walk into a local enrollment office anytime to enroll. While enrollment is mandatory only for the formal sector, for the remainder of the population, it is “construed” as voluntary although the law can be interpreted as being mandatory. There is an ongoing debate on the issue of mandated versus voluntary enrollment. Enrollment in PhilHealth is by family so the premium paid covers the member, the spouse, eligible children (those less than 21 years of age), and eligible parents (those 60 years and above and who depend financially on the member). Given that enrollment is by family, documentation of proof of marriage and birth(s) are required before spouses and children are enrolled. This is a problem for indigenous population as they usually do not have marriage and birth certificates. While the country has achieved significant strides in moving towards universal enrollment, covering the poor and informal sectors remains a challenge, with methods to enroll these populations through organized groups gaining very little traction. There is much ongoing discussion regarding the need for the central government to finance and/or subsidize the enrollment of the nation’s entire poor population. Leaving financial responsibility for insuring the poorest to local governments, coupled with a refusal to outright declare insurance as mandatory for all populations, makes it nearly impossible for the government to reach universal health coverage. It also forces PhilHealth to invest heavily in marketing campaigns for the program to local governments. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mexico: Seguro Popular |
|
48 million |
Enrollment in the SP takes place on a per-family basis. A family is composed of the father and/or mother, children and adopted children younger than eighteen or minors younger than eighteen who are dependents and live in the same household, those older than sixty-four years of age who live in the same household, single student children up to age twenty-five, and disabled children. Upon enrollment, families receive a pamphlet with their rights and duties that outlines the health interventions and services to which they are entitled. Read full sectionEnrollment in the SP takes place on a per-family basis. A family is composed of the father and/or mother, children and adopted children younger than eighteen or minors younger than eighteen who are dependents and live in the same household, those older than sixty-four years of age who live in the same household, single student children up to age twenty-five, and disabled children. Upon enrollment, families receive a pamphlet with their rights and duties that outlines the health interventions and services to which they are entitled. The SP was intended to be rolled out at the health center level. Regions were permitted to enroll individuals only if they had sufficient facilities and human resources to provide adequate care under the program. Enrollment took place at the municipal level, which meant that many municipalities without adequate facilities were not initially able to accommodate large-scale enrollment. State ministries of health are responsible for promotion of the SP program. Voluntary affiliation takes place on a quarterly basis, but enrollees must wait until the following trimester to begin receiving services. Due to the voluntary nature of the program, enrollees must choose to re-enroll annually. At the start of the program, the primary strategies for enrollment focused on large-scale affiliation campaigns for vulnerable families. Strategies that have been used to aid in the enrollment and re-enrollment process have included the following: coordinating enrollment activities with other programs targeted to poor populations; promoting enrollment in public gathering places like markets and health clinics; communicating with state and local governments to help identify priority populations; collaborating with local governments to speed the processing of official documentation; re-enrollment invitations through mass-mailings to current enrollees; using mass-marketing campaigns to motivate re-enrollment; and launching special brigades for special enrollment campaigns in localities with low levels of enrollment or re-enrollment. However, due to the fact that there were annual quotas on the number of new enrollees, certain states limited the size of their communication campaigns. During the first years of the SP targeted populations were given priority affiliation. These included those living in rural regions, those who belonged to poverty alleviating programs such as Oportunidades, and indigenous populations. As of 2009, special targeted populations included newborns and pregnant women. Moreover, the last few years have seen the growth of unemployment leading many families to lose their rights to public services such as IMSS or ISSSTE, which has led to an expansion of the enrollment goals for SP beyond what had previously been established. During the two years of the pilot program between 2001 and 2003, 614,000 families were affiliated. By the end of 2006, this number had increased to 4 million families. In terms of percentages, in 2005 the SPSS covered approximately 14% of the previously uninsured population. By 2009, this number had reached in excess of 90% of the uninsured. Table 1: Affiliation Coverage per State, 2009
Source: Secretaria de Salud Seguro PopularPopulation covered Target Populations: Below Poverty Line, Informal Sector
Coverage Level: 48 million Enrollment in the SP takes place on a per-family basis. A family is composed of the father and/or mother, children and adopted children younger than eighteen or minors younger than eighteen who are dependents and live in the same household, those older than sixty-four years of age who live in the same household, single student children up to age twenty-five, and disabled children. Upon enrollment, families receive a pamphlet with their rights and duties that outlines the health interventions and services to which they are entitled. The SP was intended to be rolled out at the health center level. Regions were permitted to enroll individuals only if they had sufficient facilities and human resources to provide adequate care under the program. Enrollment took place at the municipal level, which meant that many municipalities without adequate facilities were not initially able to accommodate large-scale enrollment. State ministries of health are responsible for promotion of the SP program. Voluntary affiliation takes place on a quarterly basis, but enrollees must wait until the following trimester to begin receiving services. Due to the voluntary nature of the program, enrollees must choose to re-enroll annually. At the start of the program, the primary strategies for enrollment focused on large-scale affiliation campaigns for vulnerable families. Strategies that have been used to aid in the enrollment and re-enrollment process have included the following: coordinating enrollment activities with other programs targeted to poor populations; promoting enrollment in public gathering places like markets and health clinics; communicating with state and local governments to help identify priority populations; collaborating with local governments to speed the processing of official documentation; re-enrollment invitations through mass-mailings to current enrollees; using mass-marketing campaigns to motivate re-enrollment; and launching special brigades for special enrollment campaigns in localities with low levels of enrollment or re-enrollment. However, due to the fact that there were annual quotas on the number of new enrollees, certain states limited the size of their communication campaigns. During the first years of the SP targeted populations were given priority affiliation. These included those living in rural regions, those who belonged to poverty alleviating programs such as Oportunidades, and indigenous populations. As of 2009, special targeted populations included newborns and pregnant women. Moreover, the last few years have seen the growth of unemployment leading many families to lose their rights to public services such as IMSS or ISSSTE, which has led to an expansion of the enrollment goals for SP beyond what had previously been established. During the two years of the pilot program between 2001 and 2003, 614,000 families were affiliated. By the end of 2006, this number had increased to 4 million families. In terms of percentages, in 2005 the SPSS covered approximately 14% of the previously uninsured population. By 2009, this number had reached in excess of 90% of the uninsured. Table 1: Affiliation Coverage per State, 2009
Source: Secretaria de Salud |
